...regard to the history of the subject, to the settled meaning of the words " money bills" at the time of the adoption of the Constitution of the Commonwealth,...Government, or bestow it upon individuals or corporations; and Therefore, that the questions proposed by the Honorable Senate and the Honorable House of Representatives...

...regard to the history of the subject, to the settled meaning of the words " money bills " at the time of the adoption of the Constitution of the Commonwealth,...Government, or bestow it upon individuals or corporations ; and Therefore, that the questions proposed by the Honorable Senate and the Honorable House of Representatives...

...bills, under the provisions of the Constitution above recited, as defined by the Supreme Judicial Court, is ' limited to bills that transfer money or property...Government or bestow it upon individuals or corporations ' (Opinion of the Justices, 1878). While the Senate can therefore, equally with the House, appropriate...

...years, we are of opinion that the exclusive constitutional privilege of the House of Eepresentatives to originate money bills is limited to bills that...government, or bestow it upon individuals or corporations. . . . HORACE GRAY, MARCUS MORTON, JAMES D. COLT, WILLIAM C. ENDICOTT, SETH AMES, OTIS P. LORD, AUGUSTUS...

...contemporaneous construction of that Constitution by the justices of the Supreme Judicial Court and by l>oth Houses of the Legislature, affirmed by a continuous...government, or bestow it upon individuals or corporations. . . . HORACE ОКАУ, MARCUS MORTON, JAMES D. COLT, WILLIAM C. ENDICOTT, SETH AMES, OTIS P. LORD,...

...originate money bilis is limited to the bills that transfer money or property from the people totbe state, and does not include bills that appropriate...government, or bestow it upon individuals or corporations." Opinion of The Justices. 138 Mass. 557. In Dundee Mortg. Trust Invest. Co. v. Parrisb, 24 Fed. Hep....

...— " All money bills shall originate in the Souse of Representatives." The exclusive constitutioDal privilege of the House of Representatives to originate...government or bestow it upon individuals or corporations. The Senate can originate a bill or resolve appropriating money from the treasury of the Commonwealth,...

...House of Representatives; but the Senate may propose or concur with amendments, as on other bills. — "The exclusive constitutional privilege of the House...Government, or bestow it upon individuals or corporations." Opinion of Justices, 126 Mass. 557, 601. This article does not relate to bills for the apportionment...

...of Representatives; but the Senate may propose or concur with amendments, as on other bills. — 143 property from the people to the State, and does not...Government, or bestow it upon individuals or corporations." Opinion of Justices, 126 Mass. 557, 601. This article does not relate to bills for the apportionment...

...originate money bills is limited to bills that provide for the levy of a tax and thus transfer money from the people to the state, and does not include bills that appropriate money from the treasury for particular public uses.1 It has also been held that the Senate has an equal right with the House...