Embowell'd with outrageous noife the air,. Though standing elfe as rocks, but down they fell By quick contraction or remove; but now jected, that it is as much as to fay, the roar filled the air with roar. Neither do I fee how the matter is much mended, by faying, with Dr. Pearce, that "The roar of cannon, embowell'd with roar, tore the air &c." The cannon, I think, cannot themselves be properly faid to be embowell'd with noife, though they might embowel with noife the air. I would therefore endeavour to justify this by other fimilar paffages. It is ufual with the poets to put the property of a thing for the thing itfelf: And as in B. ii. 654 we have "a cry of Hell-bounds" for the Hell-hounds themselves; fo here we have "the roar of cannon" for the cannon themfelves; and the roar of cannon may as properly be faid to embowel the air with out rageous noife, as a cry of Hell-hounds to bark. NEWTON. Ver. 592 That, whom they hit, &c.] This paffage is as much fuperiour to Taffo's, as the Angels' are in their nature to man. Fairfax, B. xi. ft. 60. "With good fortune fo their blowes they give, BOWLE. Nor ferv'd it to relax their ferried files. What should they do? if on they rush'd, repulse Repeated, and indecent overthrow 601 Doubled, would render them yet more defpis'd, 605 O Friends! why come not on these victors proud? 611 Ere while they fierce were coming; and when we, terms Of compofition, ftraight they chang'd their minds, Flew off, and into ftrange vagaries fell, As they would dance; yet for a dance they 615 feem'd Somewhat extravagant and wild; perhaps For joy of offer'd peace: But I fuppose, If our propofals once again were heard, We should compel them to a quick result. To whom thus Belial, in like gamefome mood. Ver. 599. 619 their ferried files.] The Italian word ferrato, clofe, compact. THYER. Ver. 620. To whom thus Belial] Whoever remembers the character of Belial in the firft and fecond books, and Addifon's remarks upon it, will eafily fee the propriety of making Belial Leader! the terms we fent were terms of weight, arms 630 635 Against fuch hellish mischief fit to oppose. 640 reply to Satan upon this occafion, and in this fportive manner, rather than Beel-zebub, or Moloch, or any of the evil Angels. NEWTON. Ver. 625. Had need from head to foot well understand; Not understood, this gift they have &c.] This miferable equivocation has been adopted from Shakspeare, Twe Gent, Verona, A. ii. S. v. "My ftaff understands me, &c." found them arms] Virgil, En. i, JOHNSON. "Furor arma miniftrat." NEWTON. Ver. 635. Rage 150. Light as the lightning glimpse they ran, they flew; 650 655 "In fhady forefts from their baggy top.”” And thus, in Lycidas, v. 54. "Nor on the baggy top of Mona high.” Glover has copied the expreffion, Leonidas, B. ii. 165. Or thofe tall cliffs erect their shaggy tops." Ver. 646. Uplifting bore them in their hands:] Hefiod, Theog. v.673. Οἱ τότε Τιτήνεσσι κατέσαθεν ἐν δαὶ λυγρῇ, Πέτρας ηλιβάτες σιβαρῆς ἐν χερσὶν ἔχοντες. Ver. 656. Their armour help'd their harm,] Somewhat like that in Spenfer, Faer. Qu. i. xi. 27. "That erft him goodly arm'd, now most of all him barm'd.” NEWTON. Into their substance pent, which wrought them pain Implacable, and many a dolorous groan ; uptore: 665 Ver. 661. now grofs by finning grown.] What a fine moral does Milton here inculcate, and indeed quite through this book, by fhowing that all the weakness and pain of the rebel Angels was the natural confequence of their finning! And, I believe, one may obferve in general of our author, that he is fcarcely ever fo far hurried on by the fire of his Mufe, as to forget the main end of all good writing, the recommendation of virtue and religion. THYER. Ver. 666. That under ground they fought in difmal shade ;] It was a memorable faying of one of the Spartans at Thermopyla, who being told that the multitude of Perfian arrows would obfcure the fun; why then, fays he, we shall fight in the fade. I fuppofe that Statius alluded to this story in the following bold lines, Thebaid, viii. 412. "Exclufere diem telis, ftant ferrea cœlo "Nubila, nec jaculis arctatus fufficit aër.” But what was a fhade of arrows to à fhade of mountains hurled to and fro, and encountering in mid air! This was infernal noife indeed, and making almost a Hell of Heaven. Such was the uproar in Hell, B. ii. 539. "Others with vaft Typhoan rage more fell "Rend up both rocks and hills, and ride the air |